Choose my Hurdy

Tell us about your instrument, share your experiences

Choose my Hurdy

Postby xuanucu » Thu Jan 19, 2012 9:42 pm

Hi!!!
As I said in my introducing I'm looking for an hurdy. I'm a completly beginner so I don't need somethig complicated and expensive. May be one or two melody strings, two drones and a trumpet. Whith these features I found some makers.

Neil Brook and his "Wren" http://hurdy-gurdy.org.uk/wren.html
Helmut seibet's "Pilgrim" http://www.saitenklang.de/english/pilgrim_hg.htm
George Levett and "Gypsy" http://altarwind.com/hurdy/gypsy.html
and
Kurt Reichmann mit "Chromatische" http://www.kurtreichmann.de/node/24

My tecnical doubts are: one or two melody strings?
mechanical tunnig pegs?
Anybody knows who is the better one of these four makers?


Many many many thanks!!!!

Juan
xuanucu
 
Posts: 3
Joined: Thu Jan 19, 2012 5:36 pm

Re: Choose my Hurdy

Postby WaterPig Master » Sat Jan 21, 2012 7:38 pm

Hi there,

Choosing an instrument is tricky. Please bear in mind that what follows are my opinions based on what I've seen, heard and played.

Neil Brook is an excellent maker. His Wrens are wonderful little gurdies, with affordable cases. I've seen several and played one. They had very light keyboards, and good biting chiens.

I hadn't heard of Helmut Seibert, but from his website I'm impressed. His designs look a little bulky for my tastes, but they look to be fairly good little gurdies. Not having ever played one, I can't say for sure.

I've played a 'top of the range' George Leverett gurdy and it was very poor. A weak sound, economy tuners (always shell out on good tuners/pegs. It will be worth it), and generally poor construction (e.g. I could see a pile of congealed sawdust through the roughly cut, oversized wheel hole). I hear his work has improved, which would be good, but he's not someone I can recommend until I play a really good instrument of his.

Kurt Reichmann is a good maker. I've played one of his gurdies (belonging to Bridget Haplin on here), and it was well constructed and had a lovely sound. When I tried it the keyboard was rather stiff, but I hear she's sorted that out now.

There are a fair number of second hand instruments around, too. In a month or two I'll be wanting to sell or hire out my Chris Allen symphonie, which is a lovely little instrument. It's perfect for a beginner (it has mechanical geared machine heads, which simplifies tuning a whole lot), if you can bear to wait that long! :) Then again, most makers have a fairly long waiting list.

RE number of melody strings: I've rarely ever seen instruments with one melody string. They're usually tiny little 'medieval' models, electric gurdies or ultra budget compact instruments. I would go with two strings.

Hope that helps!

Barnaby
Most buskers aren't tramps... Most!
User avatar
WaterPig Master
 
Posts: 138
Joined: Tue May 19, 2009 7:33 pm

Re: Choose my Hurdy

Postby xuanucu » Mon Feb 06, 2012 10:07 am

Many thanks for your answer!!!
At last but not lost I`ve decided for some locar builders which will make me easier fix any problem on my instrument. Prices and waiting list are almost the same. Good quality instruments close of mi home. If you want to take a wiew look at these.

http://rebolloinstruments.com/galeria.html
http://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set= ... 056&type=3

Many thanks again

Juan
xuanucu
 
Posts: 3
Joined: Thu Jan 19, 2012 5:36 pm


Return to Instrument reviews

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

cron